John had always been a careful driver. No speeding tickets, no accidents, and a spotless record. But when his car insurance renewal arrived with a premium hike, he was stunned. “How can it go up when I’ve done everything right?” he muttered, staring at the email.
Determined to get to the bottom of it, John started doing some research. He learned that premiums could rise due to factors beyond his control such as regional accident rates, supply chain issues in repairing cars, an increase in natural disasters, and inflation. He also discovered that a person’s credit score plays a role in determining premium price. Who knew that improving your credit score can lower your rates?
Whether you're a seasoned motorist or a new driver, understanding the factors that influence your insurance rates can help you take control of your costs. From adjusting your coverage to leveraging discounts, there are practical strategies that can lead to significant savings.
Shop Around and Compare Rates
The first step in finding a lower premium is to get at least three quotes from different insurance carriers. The best time to do this is before your policy renewal or after a major life change, such as marriage.
Even if you aren’t planning to switch insurers, it’s wise to review your policy annually to ensure it still fits your needs.
If you’re buying a new car, check the insurance rates for that specific model. The make, model and safety rating of a vehicle affect the premium. Cars that are cheaper to repair generally cost less to insure. Many insurers offer discounts for certain safety features. If the cost is a concern, avoid purchasing a luxury or sports car.
Hidden Discounts You Might Be Missing
Ask your insurers about lesser-known discounts, such as higher education discounts and having a membership with organizations such as AAA or AARP.
Driver Behavior Analytics
Another way to help lower premiums is through Driver Monitoring Programs, also known as telematics or usage-based insurance. These programs collect data on driving behaviors such as harsh braking, speeding, GPS location, trip distance, engine performance, and seatbelt usage allowing insurers to generate detailed reports and insights.
Some car manufacturers, like GM with OnStar and Ford with FordPass, offer built-in telematics systems. Additionally, aftermarket plug-in devices and smartphone apps can provide similar tracking capabilities.
Insurers use this data to assess risk more accurately, reward safe driving habits, and offer personalized premium pricing based on actual driving behavior. Ask your insurer if they offer this discount but be aware if the data reveals risky habits, it could result in higher rates.
Is Full Coverage Still Worth It?
Raising your deductible—from $500 to $1,000, for example—can reduce your collision and comprehensive coverage costs by 15–30 percent. But it also means paying more out-of-pocket if you file a claim.
For older vehicles, full coverage that includes liability, collision and comprehensive insurance may no longer be necessary. Also, depending on your lifestyle, you might consider dropping optional features like roadside assistance or rental reimbursement if they’re not essential. Speak to your financial planner about how to determine if reducing your coverage to liability only, which only pays if you damage another person’s property or injure someone, is right for you.
Consider Smaller or Regional Insurers
Local insurance companies may offer competitive rates and personalized service. You can also find discounts through group insurance plans offered by credit unions, alumni associations, employers and other organizations.
Know Your State’s Rules
Insurance regulations vary by state. Some states restrict the use of credit scores or mandate specific coverage like liability. Others may not require uninsured motorist coverage.
Insurers also assess geographic risk factors—accident and theft rates, weather patterns, road conditions, and repair costs. States differ in liability coverage requirements and may include additional types like personal injury protection or underinsured motorist coverage.
Think Twice Before Filing a Claim
Filing a claim—even if it’s not your fault—can impact your rate. Multiple claims in a short period may lead to premium increases or even non-renewal of your policy.
Take this example: you accidentally back into a pole and cause minor damage to your own car. In situations like this, it might be smarter to pay for the repairs out of pocket—or even delay fixing cosmetic issues like dents or scratches until it’s more affordable. In another example, if you have a $500 or $1,000 deductible, but the repair to your car costs less than your deductible, filing a claim probably won’t benefit you financially. Your car insurance won’t cover the cost of the repair because you haven’t met your deductible. You can always get a repair estimate from a trusted mechanic to determine whether to contact your insurer.
However, if you’re involved in an accident that causes damage to someone else’s vehicle or property—or worse, results in injury—you should always file a claim. Even if the damage is minor, making a private payment arrangement could backfire. The other party might later demand more money, and without a formal claim, you could be left unprotected.
Final Notes Before You Hit the Road
Auto insurance premiums can feel unpredictable, even for drivers like John who do everything right. But by keeping informed and proactive, you can make decisions that lead to real savings. Understanding your state’s insurance rules and knowing when (or when not) to file a claim also helps you avoid surprises.
Ultimately, managing your auto insurance isn’t just about protecting your vehicle. It’s about protecting your financial well-being. With the right strategies, you can stay ahead of rising costs and keep your coverage working for you.
The content of this article is for informational purposes only. The information does not constitute any financial, insurance, investment, legal, or tax advice. MMBB is not liable for any success or failure that is directly or indirectly related to the use of the information.
Translations of any materials into languages other than English are intended solely as a convenience to the non-English-reading public. We have attempted to provide an accurate translation of the original material in English, but due to the nuances in translating to a foreign language, slight differences may exist.
Las traducciones de cualquier material a idiomas que no sean el inglés son para la conveniencia de aquellos que no leen inglés. Hemos intentado proporcionar una traducción precisa del material original en inglés, pero debido a las diferencias de la traducción a un idioma extranjero, pueden existir ligeras diferencias.
You will be linking to another website not owned or operated by MMBB. MMBB is not responsible for the availability or content of this website and does not represent either the linked website or you, should you enter into a transaction. The inclusion of any hyperlink does not imply any endorsement, investigation, verification or monitoring by MMBB of any information in any hyperlinked site. We encourage you to review their privacy and security policies which may differ from MMBB.
If you “Proceed”, the link will open in a new window.
Back to Top
Next